No, it ain't "Laura," but it's pretty damn good This is pretty much a lost noir of the 40s, not on video and rarely shown on TV. Too bad, because it was Otto Preminger's follow up to "Laura," and it's pretty damn good. All the traditional noir elements are in place: a drifter, Dana Andrews, who sails into town on a bus, hooks up with a sultry waitress, Linda Darnell, and romances an old maid, Alice Faye, with plans to swindle her and run off with the waitress. And then, of course, there's a murder. The film is brim full of atmosphere -- shadowy scenes in the hash house where Darnell works, a song that keeps playing on a jukebox, a la the "Laura" theme (and by the same composer, David Raskin), lots of sharp, smarmy character actors on the edge of things. The mystery is fairly compelling and the film stands up very well for something made more than half a century ago.
Dana Andrews is rock solid as the shifty drifter, who might, just might, be a little better than he thinks he is. Linda Darnell is senstational as the waitress, hard, calculating and incredibly voluptuous. Her close-ups are the equal of Rita Hayworth and Gene Tierney in the forties.
Reportedly, Alice Faye left Fox after she lost several scenes in the editing room, where Zanuck decreed that the film should play up Darnell and her carnal allure. But Zanuck was right. Darnell is sensational and Alice Faye is not touching as the old maid. She's about ten years too old for the role and looks matronly. She probably shouldn't be blamed for her misconcieved performance since she was miscast in the first place. Had Zanuck cast Dorothy McGuire, or some other, younger woman who had a modest, touching quality, the contrast to Darnell's sluttishness would have been far greater and audiences would have cared more about what happens to the old maid.
Even with this flaw, however, the film is a little gem, well worth trying to catch. With a more appropriate actress in Faye's role, this might have been a major noir.
Great scene: Andrews walk into the diner where Darnell works and hears the film's theme, a low, sultry love ballad, playing on the jukebox for the umpteenth time. "Does that song play all day long?" he grouse to Darnell. Bored as hell, she rings up a sale on the cash register and, without even looking at him, snaps back, "I like it." Great stuff!