An indisputable masterpiece in storytelling, cinematorgraphy, acting and direction, the film was captivating from beginning to end despite Villeneuve's signature slow burn approach. Before I saw this film, I never thought Villeneuve could ever top the slew of great films he made thoughout the 2010s. This statement seems irrelevant considering that his magnum opus came out long before all his English language ventures.
The best aspect of Incendies is its direction. Villeneuve's direction is smart and meticulous. This is a patient, methodical film that knows exactly how to deliver its emotional punches and heighten drama, while maintaining a consistent tone and style throughout. Some of the shots are sweeping and establish a great sense of scale. On a technical level, the film is pretty flawless.
There are many gems in this movie. These are only some of many memorable scenes that I find note-worthy.
- The careful build up in the desert bus ambush. The average director would not spend so much time showing a character entering a bus and all the people around her, but these directorial touches are what make Villeneuve such a unique talent. The sequence of the ambush is very tense, and a huge part of it is due to the element of unpredictablility that Villeneuve infuses into every shot. This scene foreshadows similar brilliant moments in his later works, notably the highway scene in Sicario.
- The still reaction shot of the sister's face as the school janitor reveals the truth about his mother. The camera is unflinching as the graphical details are described, and tears flows midway through the scene. It is a powerful moment that features expert executiona and incredible acting.
- The clever writing in the meeting to track down Chamseddine. The local claims to not know Nihal of May and immediately asks for the brother's identity. The brother smirks, finding the gangster's code rather banal in the way it is presented to him. Such a smart scene, where character motivation's are naturally and subtly delivered to the audience.
Villeneuve hides critical information from his audience, and reveals them in all sorts of creative ways. He would let certain scenes play out organically, and in others he would use editing to his advantage and achieve beautiful symphony between image and dialogue. The camera is moved so confidently, with a singlular intent to show information carefully and methodically. So many moments packed with details and clever touches. Villeneuve films are always a blast, and its appeal is very evident here.
The cinematography is gorgeous, using a consistent palette of cold colours to paint the vistas of the Middle East. The acting is top-tier. The actors who played the sister and mother are phenomenal in their roles. The narrative is interesting. The film jumps frequently between flashbacks to show the late mother's perspective of her experiences, as her children revisits those same places in the current timeline, collecting the puzzle pieces containing mother's backstory and the shocking truths along with it. Very intriguing.
Speaking of which, the film tells a very interesting, moving story. It is a searing tale that begin with two siblings tracing the life of their recently passed mother as they searches for hints of lost family members. The film is mostly set in the middle east and depicts a turbulent, despondant world, where at the centre of it all lies an incredibly human tale of love, preserverance, morality, ultimately forgiveness. The character of the mother is tough, independent, and upright. Her quest for survival in a brutal world is inspirational. However, it is only by the end of the film is the full picture of the film's core themes and ideas laid bare for all to see.
It took me a moment to figure out the twist, but I did it before the film straight up told me that (the only blemish I have with the film). The film would still be powerful enough without the twist. I would have accepted an ending where both of the targets of interests were actually dead, and whole expedition being a bust. Of course, such a nihilistic approach, redolent of a Colan brother film, would be too much to bear for a lot of people. Looking back on his entire filmography, Villeneuve is like a big fan of twists. There is no problem in that, considering how well executed every twist in his films is, including this. (DV twists that are considered great: Incendies, Enemy, Prisoners, Arrival, Blade Runner, wow that's almost all his films)
Incendies is a veritable masterpiece that further accentuates how good of a year 2010 is for film. Usually, everything the same director works on goes down hill from here, considering how hard it is to top a film with such quality. In my opinion, while Incendies is the most perfect film he has made, his later films are far greater in scale and tackles genres that never saw the same treatment being applied before. In this sense, I'd say the brilliance of Incendies are overshadowed by his more ambitious, almost equally great works. Blade Runner 2049 is one of my favourite films of all time, and I am more familiar with Prisoners and Arrival. I don't think it is shame when a director's oeuvre is so varied and consistently high quality that some great works are shunned. Also, I would rather see him make another Blade Runner 2049 than another Incendies, because it is a mark of growth for a great director making his way up the ladder. I look forward to seeing Dune, but Incendies will always hold a place in my heart.