Sweet and cute I honestly had no expectations for this movie. Disney live actions have all been quite bad except for Cinderella. But I was really surprised to see this was actually enjoyable although very flawed.
First of all, the things I didnt like: Changing the musical intro with Ariel Sisters to just a reunion with triton.
NO palace, where is that gorgeous golden structure from the original movie, here it's just some rock formations, lazy.
The wardrobe, specially Ariel's, where was the pink and silver dress, or something similar that was more appealing than what they gave her.
Javier Bardem, I found him too one dimensional, maybe it is the writing or director's fault cause we all know he's an amazing actor
But the main thing I didnt like were the visuals in the underwater scenes, the mermaid movements, everything looks too plastic and fake, the part where triton destroys Ariel's stuff should have been amazing to look at but it was very meh. There are some really beautiful shots underwater but I definitely enjoyed the on land part of the movie a lot more. Not only visually but I felt like the movie started to flow a lot better after Ariel gets her legs
Now the parts I did like:
Halle's voice is just beautiful, like an angel, I even got goosebumps in some parts
The music, the new renditions were ok, especially Ariel's songs, and the new songs were not bad at all, my favorite one was the one she sings in her head after arriving on land. The scuttle rap was terrible though
And my favorite change/addition was Ariel's and Eric's relationship. It is expanded so much more, they share more time together, they discover they have the same interests, they have a really nice scene where he is showing her all her stuff. Ariel's fascination with the human world is also expanded more here.
Overall, it is far from Disney's worst live action and it is far from being a masterpiece or anything. Was it necessary? No, is there any reason to watch it besides it being the live action of the animated classic? No, what I mean by this is that, there are some Disney Live Actions that stand on their own, for example, Alice in wonderland, 101 dalmatians, Cinderella, you watch those because they are their own thing. This one is in the same category as aladdin and beauty and the beast where it feels like a shot for shot remake, a bit better than those two, but still not saying much. It was a sweet conventional movie, despite of what the controversy might make you think, this was very conventional.