Star Trek's Most Aimless Incarnation Admittedly, I'm only 3 seasons into the show, but I find Star Trek: Discovery puzzling. I think it's the first Star Trek without a point of view or direction. The original show was all about exploring the galaxy, The Next Generation was the continuing voyages, Deep Space Nine was all about the galaxy coming to a space truck stop and so on so forth. But Discovery, what's the mission statement here? The 1st season was this war with the Klingons. The 2nd season was about following seven red lights and an advert/road test for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds. THe 3rd season is all about digging itself out of the continuity hole Discovery for being all out of whack with the Star Trek canon.
The show does seem to have made a rod for its own back with its continuity issues. Essentially, despite being set 10yrs before the original Star Trek TV show, they have better technology, the mushroom drive, different uniforms, etc. Something they used season 2 to paper over the paradoxical cracks.
It's weird they didn't make Michael Burnham captain. As an officer who has to work with a host of captains. No one is captain of Discovery for more than 10 minutes at a time. She's the lead character but not in charge is a weird setup. It robs her character of importance, especially when Pike was in charge.
There's a professionalism issue with the show. No Discovery character can follow orders! Everyone is going rogue. Not mention Tilly. There's no way someone that unprofessional would be an officer on a cruise ship let alone a starship.
The biggest failing is that it misses the point of what Star Trek is all about. Great allegories about the human condition told as sci-fi. The Next Generation nailed this so well. So many great stories. What do we get with Discovery? A lot of technobabble reeled off at speed, lens flares and annoying camera moves (I'm looking at you 2nd season). Sadly, it's style over very little substance.