i think JTYJN is a good light romantic comedy movie...but not great as many people are suggesting Story line is very good but dialogs are looking as they have been imposed rather than free flowing conversation (well this is the case with almost 90% of the bollywood movies) I think most of the bollywood directors don't know how to use indirect communications (like pause, eye contact, and other contextual suggestions) techniques...and they try to put the idea by direct verbal communications and this is when it starts to look clumsy and people loose interest in it Acting wise only main character (Aamir definitely has the potential to make it big) and some proved actors of bollwood are brilliant and rest of the crowd is average or below average (especially the friends of protagonists...i am really disappointed by the new second line actors coming to Bollywood Still i would recommend to watch the movie especially nowadays its rarity that Bollywood comes with some refreshing theme