I should probably begin by saying that I'm not the target audience for a Christian propaganda film like this. That said, The Woodcarver managed to occasionally catch my interest, due in a large part to the acting skills of John Ratzenberger and the honest beauty in the woodworking highlighted in the movie.
The plot of the movie is fairly straight forward, without any real surprises. The plot is focused on Ernest, an elderly woodworker played by the talented John Ratzenberger, and Matthew, a troubled teenager who begins the movie by vandalizing the church that Ernest is working to rebuild. The pastor of the vandalized church convinces Matthew to work with Ernest in order to repay the damage he caused. In the process of working with the boy, Ernest manages to impart his work ethic, values, and beliefs onto the boy, simply by living well and asking Matthew to stop before doing anything and first asking "What would Jesus do?"
Before I complain about the lackluster plot and acting in the movie, I should first give the praise where it is due. John Ratzenberger acts his role well, and I found myself most interested in the movie when he was on screen. The director also seemed to understand the beauty in the woodcarving scenes, which were lovingly filmed and liberally sprinkled throughout the movie. The sets are well-designed, and Ernest's house is filled with the little touches that mark it as the home of a skilled carpenter.
Unfortunately, that's it for the praise. The plot isn't bad, but is boring and predictable. Ernest, the 'good Christian', never seems to do anything wrong and has no flaws in his character to speak of. It's only due to the previously mentioned skills of Ratzenberger that the character manages to be at all interesting. The other actors deliver their lines without the conviction that you would expect from trained professionals, and sound more like a high school theatre troupe that has yet to come into their talent. The Christian message isn't heavy handed, but the movie still manages to avoid any challenging subject matter by having everyone simply accept it without any real internal debate or struggle. The questions they ask about Ernest's Christian message are simple and foolish, but the movie still doesn't bother to properly address them.
All told, if you are a Christian family looking for something to affirm your values, this movie will do the job. If you are looking for anything thought-provoking or at all interesting, look elsewhere. The movie never manages to be bad, but in the sea of cinema available, it commits the worst sin of all: mediocrity.
1 out of 3 found this helpful