Intense and sad Tommy Lee Jones' "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada" is a mournful, strange, intense movie. Part "Pulp Fiction," part Western revenge picture, the film feels its own currents acutely, and envelops us in its threads of loss, regret, and loneliness, so that we're left feeling wrung out.
The many characters of "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada" share not an ounce of happiness between them. Jones creates an observant portrait of Texas border life, replete with lazy greasy spoon diners and depressing pre-fab mobile homes. Everyone in town seems overcome with an inexpressible melancholy. There's Mike Norton (Barry Pepper), a young border patrol agent who seems drawn to the rough work to satisfy a semi-repressed sadistic streak. His young wife idles away the days in their trailer, and looks forward to trips to the mall. The local waitress beds seemingly half the men in town, including ranch hand Pete Perkins (Jones). And there's the title character himself, whom we first meet as a rotting corpse being munched upon by coyotes, but later see in flashback in the flesh.
The film's first half uses overlapping flashbacks to reconstruct the circumstances of Melquiades' death, as it constructs its large cast of characters. For a while, we're primed to expect some revealed truth regarding his death. As it happens, though, the shooting death of an illegal Mexican is no big mystery. Accidental or not, the border patrol and local PD are not going to bother themselves with a real investigation over one more "wetback." Perkins, though, was close to Estrada. We have the distinct impression that the Mexican was, in fact, his only friend. He certainly cares enough about the dead man not only to have him dug up in order to bury him in Mexico, as per his wishes, but to kidnap Norton, whom he's been told was Melquiades' killer.
The film here moves into a lengthy, lyrical sequence subtitled "The Journey," in which the two men run (or ride) for the border. Again, though, it has a tendency to zig when a zag is what we're expecting. It's not a road trip, exactly, though both are transformed by the experience. Nor do the men bond in classic movie fashion, although they do enhance their mutual understanding. The sequence is affecting in its imagery: a horse falling to its death off a cliff hardly fazes Perkins; the extreme measures, including fire and anti-freeze, Perkins uses to preserve his friend's corpse for the journey.
Jones in particular here gives an odd performance, imbued with detached sadness. His Perkins can seem a maddening cipher. At times I was craving some back story or buried detail that might illuminate a man's motivation and ability to go calmly to such extremes. We want to know what's going on in Perkins' head as he increasingly desecrates the body of a friend whose memory he is working to sanctify. Late in the film we're given as close to an answer as we'll get. In flashback, we see Melquiades lost in recollection of the life he left in Mexico. He holds forth about his family, about mountains close enough to hug, pure spring water, and overwhelming natural beauty with a sincerity that, at the time, makes Perkins laugh. Yet for a man who is surrounded by, and indeed embodies, such sorrow, Melquiades' fond wistfulness is something worth preserving. "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada" occasionally leans toward the inscrutable, but it's a film that's hard to forget.